How To Make An Offer On Depop: The Complete Buyer's Guide To Smart Negotiation

How To Make An Offer On Depop: The Complete Buyer's Guide To Smart Negotiation

How to Deal With Lowball Offers on Depop - Karrot Market

To make an offer on Depop, locate your desired listing, select the "Make Offer" button, input a bid that complies with the platform's maximum discount thresholds, and submit it. Once sent, the seller has a strict 24-hour window to accept, decline, or counter your bid, with payment pre-authorization executing automatically upon acceptance in binding regions.


Pre-Negotiation Assessment & Buyer Verification

Before initiating any transactional negotiation on Depop, completing a foundational review of both the listing and your account settings is essential. Unlike traditional retail platforms, peer-to-peer (P2P) marketplaces rely heavily on real-time seller engagement and automated payment gateways. If your payment methods are outdated or if you submit an offer on an inactive listing, you risk tieing up your purchasing power or missing out on highly competitive inventory.



Mandatory Pre-Offer Checklist



  • Essential Tools & Technical Setup: You must have the latest version of the Depop mobile application (iOS or Android) installed. Desktop web browsers support browsing but often lack the full-suite UI features required for seamless binding offers. Additionally, ensure you have a verified payment method—such as Apple Pay, PayPal, Google Pay, or a valid credit/debit card—linked directly to your Depop wallet.
  • Prerequisite Seller Verification: Check the seller’s profile for an "Active today" or "Active this week" status indicator. Review their shop policies, average shipping times, and feedback rating (target a 4.5-star minimum across at least 10 transactions for optimal security).
  • Negotiation Parameters: Establish your maximum budget, factoring in local shipping costs, international customs (if applicable), and Depop's buyer association fees.
  • Timeline Benchmarks: Every official offer on the platform operates on a non-negotiable 24-hour expiration cycle. Plan your offers when you are active and able to monitor notifications.

Step-by-Step Depop Offer Execution & Negotiation Strategy

Navigating the negotiation process on Depop requires a balance of platform-specific technical execution and strategic pricing. Follow this step-by-step workflow to submit competitive offers that protect your capital while maximizing your acceptance rates.



Step 1: Inspect the Listing and Read the Seller's Terms

Before tapping any buttons, open the item description and read it completely. Sellers frequently outline specific shipping preferences, bundle discounts, or firm pricing structures within this space. Look for key terms such as "Firm on price," "Message before buying," or "No offers."

If the seller's description does not forbid negotiation, scroll down to check the "Active" status badge beneath their profile name. If a seller has not been online for more than a month, sending an offer is highly unlikely to yield a response, and any automatic payments processed could result in a lengthy refund process.



Step 2: Access the Interactive Offer Interface

Navigate to the bottom of the listing page. You will see two primary buttons: "Buy" and "Make Offer." Tap the "Make Offer" button. This action triggers a secure, modal pop-up screen displaying the item's original listing price, shipping cost, and an editable numeric input field where you will enter your proposed price.

Pro-Tip: If the "Make Offer" button is grayed out or missing entirely, the seller has manually opted out of the Depop offer feature for this specific listing, or they have set their profile preferences to reject manual negotiations. In this instance, your only avenue for negotiation is to send a polite, direct message (DM) to the seller.



Step 3: Calculate a Market-Rate, High-Probability Offer

Depop’s system enforces strict algorithmic guardrails on offer amounts. You cannot submit an offer that is excessively low (typically anything below 60% to 70% of the original listing price is automatically blocked by the system's API). To calculate a competitive offer that sellers will take seriously:



  1. Identify the original listing price.
  2. Calculate a 15% discount (multiply by 0.85) for a high-probability, respectful starting bid.
  3. Calculate a 30% discount (multiply by 0.70) for older listings or items with minor cosmetic wear.
  4. Input your calculated value into the numeric field. The app will immediately notify you if your number falls below the platform's minimum permitted offering threshold.


Step 4: Configure Shipping and Payment Details (Binding Offer Pre-Authorization)

Depending on your geographic region and account update status, Depop utilizes a "Binding Offers" system. When you submit an offer, you are prompted to select your shipping address and primary payment method upfront.

Warning: Treat every offer as a financial commitment. If you are in a region where binding offers are active, the platform will place a temporary pre-authorization hold on your selected payment method. The moment the seller taps "Accept," the transaction is finalized, your account is charged, and the item is officially marked as sold. You cannot back out or cancel the order after acceptance.



Step 5: Finalize and Submit the Offer

Review your total costs, which will be displayed in an itemized breakdown including your offered price, shipping fees, sales tax, and any buyer marketplace fees. Once verified, tap the "Submit Offer" button.

The system will generate an automated confirmation and send an instant push notification and in-app message directly to the seller's inbox, notifying them that an active offer is awaiting their decision.



Step 6: Monitor the 24-Hour Decision Window and Handle Counter-Offers

The seller has exactly 24 hours from the timestamp of submission to take one of three actions:



  • Accept: The item is sold to you. In binding regions, payment processes immediately. In non-binding regions, you will receive a notification to manually complete checkout within a 24-hour grace period.
  • Decline: The offer is rejected. You are free to submit a revised offer, or look for alternative listings.
  • Counter-Offer: The seller proposes a middle-ground price. You will receive a notification prompting you to accept, decline, or submit a counter-counter-offer. Treat counter-offers with the same urgency as initial offers, as the 24-hour expiration clock resets with each counter-submission.

make an offer on anything, willing to negotiate,... - Depop

make an offer on anything, willing to negotiate,... - Depop

Depop Offer Metrics & Negotiation Boundaries

To negotiate effectively, you must understand how the platform categorizes offer values and how sellers typically react to different pricing thresholds. The table below outlines these pricing structures, system limits, and response probabilities based on platform data.



Offer Category Discount Percentage Platform API Status Seller Response Probability Strategic Use Case
Low-Ball Offer 40% or more off listing price Frequently blocked by system filters Extremely low (< 5% acceptance rate) Avoid entirely. Often results in the seller blocking your profile.
Aggressive Offer 30% to 35% off listing price Allowed on most items Low to Moderate (20% to 35%) Use on listings that have been active for over 60 days or have visible flaws.
Standard Competitive 15% to 25% off listing price Fully allowed High (60% to 80% acceptance rate) The industry sweet spot. Ideal for most listings, popular brands, and active sellers.
Micro-Negotiation 5% to 10% off listing price Fully allowed Very High (> 90% acceptance rate) Best used to offset shipping costs or secure highly sought-after, trending items.

Transaction Roadblocks & Offer Failure Resolutions

When using Depop’s negotiation tools, you may encounter system errors, unresponsive users, or payment processing glitches. Below are the most common failure modes and their technical resolutions.



Scenario 1: The "Offer Cannot Be Submitted" Error Appears



  • Root Cause: The offer price you entered is below the minimum threshold allowed by Depop's system (typically more than 30% to 40% below the asking price), or the seller has set an automated threshold to decline low offers instantly.
  • Actionable Fix: Calculate the exact 30% discount limit of the item (Multiply listing price by 0.70). Adjust your offer so it is equal to or higher than this mathematical threshold, then re-submit. If the error persists, clear your app cache or attempt the offer on a stable Wi-Fi connection to rule out API timeout errors.


Scenario 2: The Seller Accepted the Offer but the Item is Still Listed (Non-Binding Regions)



  • Root Cause: You are transacting in a region where Depop has not yet fully transitioned to binding offers. In these areas, an accepted offer merely unlocks the discounted price for you, but the listing remains active and available to any buyer willing to pay full price.
  • Actionable Fix: Turn on push notifications for the Depop app. The absolute second you receive the "Offer Accepted" notification, open the app, navigate to your inbox, tap "Buy Now," and complete the checkout funnel before another user purchases the item.


Scenario 3: Payment Declined Automatically Upon Seller Acceptance (Binding Offers)



  • Root Cause: Your payment provider blocked the automated charge due to insufficient funds, an expired card, or a fraud prevention flag triggered by the rapid pre-authorization transition.
  • Actionable Fix: Open your profile settings, select the payment tab, delete the existing card, and link an updated payment method. Once updated, send a polite direct message to the seller explaining the technical glitch, and ask them to send a counter-offer for the same amount so you can re-trigger the automated checkout system.


Scenario 4: The Seller is Unresponsive and the Offer Expires



  • Root Cause: The seller is inactive on the platform, missed their app notifications, or chose to ignore the bid because they felt it was too low.
  • Actionable Fix: Check the "Active" status on the seller's profile. If they have been active recently, send a brief message: "Hi! I just sent an offer on your listing. Let me know if that price works for you, or if you'd like to counter." If they remain unresponsive, do not resubmit the offer; redirect your search to another seller.

Frequently Asked Questions



Are all offers on Depop binding?

Offers are binding for buyers in the United States and the United Kingdom who use the native iOS or Android apps with integrated payment methods. In these regions, your payment method is charged immediately upon seller acceptance. In other countries or older app versions, offers remain non-binding, requiring manual checkout after acceptance.



Can I cancel an offer after I have submitted it?

No, Depop does not currently feature a "Retract Offer" button. Once you submit an offer, it remains active and open for 24 hours. If you made a mistake, you must wait for the 24-hour window to expire, or message the seller directly asking them to decline the offer from their end.



Does my offer include the shipping cost?

No, your offer only covers the price of the physical item. Shipping fees, regional sales taxes, and buyer marketplace fees are calculated and added on top of your accepted offer price during the checkout summary phase.



What should I do if a seller counters my offer with a price that is too high?

You can choose to accept their counter-offer, decline it outright, or submit a counter-counter-offer that splits the difference. If negotiations stall, it is best to politely message the seller thanking them for their time, or walk away from the transaction.

Connect with the Circular Fashion Community

Ready to curate your sustainable wardrobe and build a unique collection? Open your Depop app now to apply these negotiation tactics and secure your next favorite piece at the perfect price point.


How to Send Offers on Depop, or Cancel Them!

How to Send Offers on Depop, or Cancel Them!

Read also: How to Remove Tape In Hair Extensions at Home Safely and Effectively