The Complete Guide To Visiting And Researching The Amityville New York House

The Complete Guide To Visiting And Researching The Amityville New York House

What happened in the Amityville house and is it still standing? | The ...

The Amityville New York house at 112 Ocean Avenue is one of the most infamous pieces of American residential real estate, steeped in tragic history and global pop-culture lore. Understanding how to legally locate, research, and evaluate the true history of this Dutch Colonial property requires separating urban legend from municipal property records, local ordinances, and true crime history.


Historical Research and Property Location Fundamentals

Navigating the geography and historical documentation of the Amityville New York house demands a structured approach to local archives, real estate databases, and municipal planning offices. Whether you are conducting architectural research, true crime analysis, or planning a respectful educational drive-by, preparation is essential to avoid trespassing, community friction, and misinformation.



  • Essential Research Materials: Suffolk County Clerk property deeds, historical Sanborn fire insurance maps, local newspaper archives (The Long Island Advance), and municipal zoning records.
  • Mandatory Prerequisite Standards: Strict adherence to New York State privacy laws, local Town of Babylon municipal parking ordinances, and private property boundaries.
  • Estimated Resource Investment: 10 to 15 hours of archival research or a 2-hour field transit; negligible financial cost unless purchasing historical documentation copies.

Step-by-Step Field Navigation and Archival Investigation



Step 1: Locating the Property and Address Verification

The actual physical structure sits in the Incorporated Village of Amityville within the Town of Babylon in Suffolk County, New York. To prevent unauthorized intrusion on private property, you must rely on public vantage points from Ocean Avenue or maritime viewing via the Amityville creek systems.



  1. Input the precise coordinates or municipal district records into your geographical mapping tool, noting that the original street address number was officially changed by local authorities to deter disruptive tourism.
  2. Verify the current street nomenclature and neighborhood boundary lines using the Suffolk County GIS mapping portal to ensure complete compliance with local zoning laws.
  3. Plan your transit route using major regional arteries such as New York State Route 27 (Sunrise Highway) or Southern State Parkway, exiting south toward Merrick Road and Ocean Avenue.

Warning: Trespassing on the private property of 112 Ocean Avenue or harassing current occupants is strictly prohibited by Suffolk County law and will result in immediate law enforcement intervention.



Step 2: Accessing Suffolk County Municipal Records

Validating the structural, ownership, and tragic criminal history of the Amityville New York house requires pulling primary-source government documentation rather than relying on cinematic adaptations or sensationalized blogs.



  1. Access the Suffolk County Clerk online database or visit the county archives in Riverhead, New York, to review the complete chain of title from the mid-20th century to the present day.
  2. Cross-reference the 1974 DeFeo family tragedy and the subsequent 1975 Lutz family occupancy using official New York State Supreme Court trial transcripts and police reports.
  3. Examine architectural blueprints and building permit histories filed with the Village of Amityville Building Department to track structural modifications, including the famous quarter-round attic windows that were altered to deter sightseers.

Pro-Tip: Always request certified copies of historical deeds when conducting formal architectural or historical property documentation to ensure absolute data accuracy.



Step 3: Conducting Architectural and Neighborhood Context Analysis

Evaluating the house within its broader architectural landscape provides a clearer understanding of mid-century Long Island suburban development and the unique aesthetic of Dutch Colonial architecture.



  1. Document the signature architectural markers of the dwelling, including its gambrel roofline, flared eaves, and symmetrical facade which are characteristic of historic Dutch Colonial designs popular in the Northeast corridor.
  2. Analyze the spatial layout of the neighborhood along Ocean Avenue, observing how waterfront access on the Amityville River shaped suburban residential expansion during the post-World War II housing boom.
  3. Review local zoning restrictions regarding historic preservation and landmark designation within the Village of Amityville to understand why the structure has not received formal historical landmark status.

With 'The Amityville Horror,' One House. Many Haunts. - The New York Times

With 'The Amityville Horror,' One House. Many Haunts. - The New York Times

Comparative Analysis of Amityville Real Estate Parameters



Parameter Historical Reality (1974–1976) Modern Status (Current Era)
Official Address 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, NY Modified street numbering for privacy
Architectural Style Dutch Colonial Renovated Dutch Colonial
Primary Market Value Moderate suburban valuation High-tier waterfront valuation
Public Accessibility Open suburban street access Restricted privacy perimeter

Common Field Challenges and Research Pitfalls



  • Incorrect Address Identification:

    • Root Cause: Municipal authorities and previous owners altered street numbers and exterior architectural features (such as removing the iconic quarter-round windows) to stop disruptive tourism.
    • Actionable Fix: Consult current Suffolk County tax maps and municipal GIS portals rather than outdated tourist blogs to locate the exact parcel.
  • Encountering Urban Legends vs. Verified Facts:

    • Root Cause: Over-reliance on supernatural horror films, fictionalized novels, and unverified internet forums.
    • Actionable Fix: Rely exclusively on primary-source police affidavits, court transcripts from the Ronald DeFeo Jr. trial, and verified newspaper archives.
  • Local Community Friction:

    • Root Cause: Excessive visitor traffic disrupting residential peace along Ocean Avenue.
    • Actionable Fix: Maintain strict compliance with local parking regulations, remain on public thoroughfares, and respect the absolute privacy of current homeowners.

Frequently Asked Questions



Where is the Amityville New York house located?

The house is located on Ocean Avenue within the Incorporated Village of Amityville in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York. To protect the privacy and security of current residents, local authorities have altered the original street number.



Can you go inside the Amityville house?

No, the Amityville New York house is a privately owned residential dwelling and is completely closed to the public. Attempting to enter the property or trespass on the grounds constitutes criminal trespassing under New York State law.



What actually happened at the Amityville house?

On November 13, 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. tragically murdered six members of his family inside the residence. One year later, in December 1975, the Lutz family moved in and claimed to experience paranormal phenomena, which inspired a best-selling book and a famous film franchise.



Why does the house look different today than it did in the movies?

Subsequent homeowners extensively renovated the exterior of the dwelling, including changing the color, replacing the siding, and altering the shape of the iconic quarter-round attic windows that resembled menacing eyes in the original media depictions.



Is the Amityville house historically landmarked?

No, the property does not hold official historical landmark status from the Village of Amityville or New York State. It remains a private residential home governed by standard local municipal zoning and real estate laws.

Begin your deep dive into Long Island architectural history today by exploring verified municipal databases and archival records for a factual understanding of the Amityville New York house.


The Infamously Haunting Story Of The Amityville Horror - New York (Lutz ...

The Infamously Haunting Story Of The Amityville Horror - New York (Lutz ...

Read also: Remote work options will soon expand for all city of lowell employees